Does Athletics Undermine Academics? Examining Some Issues
نویسنده
چکیده
When I was a graduate student at the University of Pennsylvania in the late 1960s, philosopher Paul Weiss published his ground-breaking book, Philosophy of Sport. I distinctly remember a review of the book from The New York Times being posted on the graduate student bulletin board under a sign with very large letters that said, “Write on this subject only if you already have tenure.” In retrospect, the attitude expressed by the sign conveyed a narrowness that characterized a good deal of the academic philosophy of the time. After all, sport was an important part of the culture surely worthy of study, and involved interesting philosophical issues ranging from the conceptual, such as analysis of the nature of sport, to the ethical, such as the proper role of athletic in colleges and universities. It has been heartening to see more and more scholars become engaged with issues raised by sports and now to help launch a project, initiated by the NCAA, to rigorously study intercollegiate athletics. The existentialist philosopher, Albert Camus, once remarked that the context in which he really learned ethics was that of sport. However, even if Camus learned valuable moral lessons from sport, it doesn’t follow that intercollegiate athletics is, can be, or should be a medium for moral education. Indeed, some critics will argue for the moral bankruptcy of intercollegiate athletics, citing such examples as academic fraud in one major basketball program, falsification of academic records in order to insure eligibility for an athlete at another, misbehavior including alleged criminal acts by some recruited athletes, and dismal graduation rates in some high visibility men’s programs. However, it is important to remember that intercollegiate sports occur at a wide variety of institutions, ranging over different divisions and different educational missions. The problems of some high-profile Division I programs, particularly in men’s high-visibility
منابع مشابه
Can Football Buy Smarter Students?
There is a mentality across universities that money spent on athletics might be better spent on things that directly impact the academic environment of the institution. For example, in order to better the university one may argue that money spent on upgrading the library is more appropriate than money spent on renovating the stadium. The more general issue is the conflict between spending on ac...
متن کاملسلامت و پزشکی از دیدگاه شاهنامه فردوسی
Introduction: Shahnameh , Ferdowsi Tusi valuable work, is well-known and famous epic in Persian . A poem Shahnameh heroes in the history of Iran know that its name was enduring heroes of Iran and the Persian language was in decline , I was new . But something else is the purpose of writing this article . The Shahnameh is the only Iranian athletics history or include other issues as well ? Metho...
متن کاملDoes Athletic Success Come at the Expense of Academic Success?
Claims are often made about the impact of high school athletics on academic achievement without reference to empirical research on the issue. In this paper we empirically examine the relationship between the extent to which high schools have winning sports teams, offer a variety of sports options, and facilitate student participation in athletics on schools’ overall student achievement and atta...
متن کاملSecurity First Network Bank: A Case Study of an Internet Pioneer
The US banking industry has gone through a decade of mergers and consolidations where the universal view appears to be that achieving larger scale is the only means for survival among the megabanks of the nation and the world. However, one of the smallest banks in the nation, Security First Network Bank, has shaken up traditional bankers by introducing branchless banking via the internet. The i...
متن کاملImportance-performance analysis: A valid management tool?
Importance-performance analysis (IPA) is considered a useful tool in examining customer satisfaction and management strategies. This technique can help tourism stakeholders in diagnosing underlying deficiencies and setting priorities in tourism development. As a result, a more efficient allocation of limited resources could be achieved to improve tourist satisfaction and destination competitive...
متن کامل